A Toronto print shop owner committed an act of discrimination when he turned away a job from a gay and lesbian archives organization, Ontario's Board of Inquiry has ruled, according to PrintCAN.
The decision caps a legal battle that began in April 1996, when Scott Brockie of Imaging Excellence declined to print letterhead for Ray Brillinger of the Canadian Lesbian and Gay Archives. Brockie, described in the trade publication's report as a born-again Christian, refused the work on moral grounds.
Brillinger took the matter to the Ontario Human Rights Commission, PrintCAN reported. The commission heard the complaint but chose not to render a judgment, and the case then moved to the Board of Inquiry, which found that discrimination had occurred.
"The adjudicator's decision has gone against us, but I'm not surprised," Brockie told PrintCAN.
Despite the ruling, Brockie indicated he does not consider the matter closed. He said the decision has set up a broader legal contest over which rights prevail under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"Now that they've decided the discrimination occurred, it's about whose Charter rights takes precedence," Brockie told PrintCAN, framing the dispute as a clash between his religious convictions and Brillinger's right to equal treatment.
The case has drawn attention as a test of how human rights protections apply to commercial services in Ontario. It raises the question of whether a business owner's religious beliefs can justify refusing a customer on the basis of the customer's affiliation with a group protected from discrimination.
Under the board's finding, the refusal to print the letterhead amounted to a denial of service tied to the customer's identity. Brockie's argument, as he laid it out to PrintCAN, is that being compelled to take the work would violate his own Charter protections.
The report of the ruling appeared in PrintCAN's November 1999 coverage of the Canadian printing industry. No details were given about any penalty, remedy or next procedural step flowing from the board's decision.



