Sixty-three environmental, farm and community organizations are calling on the federal government to order a full impact assessment of the Bradford Bypass, arguing the proposed highway between Highways 400 and 404 would cause serious harm to Lake Simcoe, the Holland Marsh and at-risk wildlife.
The groups made the request in a joint letter to federal Environment Minister Guilbeault, backing a designation request filed under the federal Impact Assessment Act on Nov. 9, 2021 by three community organizations: Forbid Roads Over Green Spaces, Stop the Bradford Bypass and Concerned Citizens of King Township, according to a joint letter posted by the National Farmers Union of Ontario.
The letter states the highway will result in adverse social and environmental impacts within federal jurisdiction. It notes that transportation is the largest source of greenhouse gas emissions in Ontario and warns of what it calls "serious and irreversible effects on Lake Simcoe and Ontario's climate."
It also raises the loss of farmland in the Holland Marsh, which the groups describe as an irreplaceable and finite resource.
Provincial exemption at issue
According to the letter, the Ontario cabinet passed a regulation on Oct. 7, 2021 fully approving the Bradford Bypass and exempting it from Ontario's Environmental Assessment Act. The groups say that means the project is set to proceed with minimal consultation, no consideration of alternatives, and limited studies that will have no bearing on whether it goes forward.
The letter says the province's construction timeline indicates work will begin before those studies are even released, despite several municipal requests for a comprehensive assessment of the highway's impacts on Lake Simcoe and associated watersheds.
The signatories also point to the dramatic increase in impervious surfaces the highway would bring, which they say could contaminate nearby waterbodies, including the Holland Marsh Provincially Significant Wetland, through stormwater runoff, wastewater discharge and spills.
Species at risk along the route
The letter highlights the Red-headed Woodpecker, assessed as endangered in 2018 by the Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada. It says mapped critical habitat for the species lies along the proposed route, yet the province's exemption regulation allows that habitat to be destroyed without public consultation and before environmental studies are completed.
The groups argue that alternatives to the highway with potentially much lower impacts on climate and biodiversity have not been duly considered. They contend the project's underlying premise is that compact, transit-supportive complete communities are not possible, and that everyone moving to the Lake Simcoe region in the future will drive alone.
The list of signatories includes several Simcoe County-area organizations, among them the Rescue Lake Simcoe Coalition, the Simcoe County Greenbelt Coalition, AWARE Simcoe, Nature Barrie, Sustainable Orillia, the Orillia Field Naturalists and the Friends of Simcoe Forests, alongside provincial and national groups such as Ontario Nature, Environmental Defence, the David Suzuki Foundation and the National Farmers Union of Ontario.
Citing Canada's climate commitments made at COP26 and its responsibilities for fisheries and species at risk, the groups are urging the minister to intervene and compel the province to consider alternatives to the highway through a federal impact assessment.




