SIMCOE COUNTY — Simcoe County will not pick a warden this term. Under Ontario's Better Regional Governance Act, the warden title became "County Chair" on Nov. 15, and the Province, not council, fills the job. On Nov. 10, Municipal Affairs Minister Rob Flack appointed Don McIsaac, who has been Orillia's mayor since 2022. Before politics, McIsaac was executive vice-president and chief financial officer of Cirrus Aircraft, and he is a Chartered Professional Accountant.

County council has also shrunk from 32 members to 17: the mayors of the 16 member municipalities plus the chair. The County says the deputy warden post is gone, and deputy mayors no longer sit at the county table. The County will hold its inaugural meeting on Dec. 8 at 1 p.m. to swear in the 16 mayors and McIsaac. "I'm excited," McIsaac told OrilliaMatters on the day of his appointment, but said he would not comment further until sworn in.

The outgoing warden, Ramara's Basil Clarke, had sought the job, OrilliaMatters reported. "I also recognize that the new position is not the same ... as being elected by your peers to represent them in this house," he told the final meeting of the old council.

The chair holds "Strong Chair" powers. The County says he can propose the annual budget, hire or dismiss certain division heads, create committees and appoint their chairs, and veto by-laws he believes interfere with provincial priorities such as housing. Council can override a veto with a two-thirds vote of all members.

The county table: new mayors

According to Barrie360, five incumbent mayors lost on Oct. 26: in Innisfil, New Tecumseth, Clearview, Bradford West Gwillimbury and Tiny. Ramara also has a new mayor because Clarke did not run.

Innisfil: Kenneth Fowler (NEW), the deputy mayor, defeated Mayor Lynn Dollin. Rob Nicol is deputy mayor.

Bradford West Gwillimbury: Nickolas Harper (NEW), a councillor, defeated Mayor James Leduc. Joseph G. Giordano is deputy mayor.

New Tecumseth: Stephanie MacLellan (NEW), the deputy mayor, defeated Mayor Richard Norcross. Marc Biss is deputy mayor.

Clearview: Robert McArthur (NEW), a councillor, defeated Mayor Doug Measures. Justin McGilvray is deputy mayor.

Tiny: Dave Brunelle (NEW), a councillor, defeated Mayor David Evans. Karen Zulynik is deputy mayor.

Ramara: Keith Bell (NEW), the deputy mayor, won an open race. Joe Gough is deputy mayor.

Returning mayors are Jennifer Coughlin (Springwater), Randy Greenlaw (Oro-Medonte), Sandie Macdonald (Essa), Mike Burkett (Severn), Scott W. Anderson (Adjala-Tosorontio), Yvonne Hamlin (Collingwood), Bill Gordon (Midland), Brian Smith (Wasaga Beach), and Doug Rawson (Penetanguishene) and Ted Walker (Tay), who were both acclaimed.

The Voice found no campaign platforms for the six new mayors in the sources reviewed, so it reports none.

Barrie and Orillia

Barrie and Orillia are separated cities. They are not members of County council, but the County delivers paramedic and social services to both.

Barrie: Alex Nuttall (returning). Nuttall won a second term with 26,054 votes (66.62 per cent), ahead of Tanya Saari's 9,898. Turnout was 30.21 per cent, according to the City's certified results. Council's inaugural meeting was scheduled for Nov. 18, and its agenda included a by-law appointing a deputy mayor. As of Nov. 18, the Voice had no report from that meeting.

On election night Nuttall called the result a mandate for "stability" and "steadiness." He also said, "There's no way that we could fully get all of the finances of the city in the place we will want them to be in just a four-year term," Barrie360 reported. His promises include $3 million for traffic calming, 2,000 new manufacturing jobs and 800 affordable housing units. The City's 2026 budget, prepared under strong-mayor rules, held the City operating levy at 0 per cent for a fourth straight year. It kept a 2 per cent infrastructure levy, which costs the average household about $104.

Orillia: Steve Clarke (returning former mayor). Clarke was mayor from 2014 to 2022. He beat Ward 1 Coun. Whitney Smith 7,569 votes to 1,690 to succeed McIsaac, according to the City's certificate of results. He named homelessness his top priority and building the new hospital his second. Orillia's council is inaugurated on Nov. 23.

Taxes and services

The county levy. The County's 2026 budget was $1.042 billion, made up of $745.1 million for operations and $297 million for capital. It raised the County portion of property taxes by 3.5 per cent: 2 points for operations and capital, and 1.5 points for asset management. The County says that works out to about $10.86 per $100,000 of assessment.

The County runs paramedics, social and community services, child care system management, social housing and county roads. Under the new rules, McIsaac, not council, will table the 2027 budget.

Timing. Ontario Regulation 189/26 says the budget for the year after an election can be proposed only in that year. Strong-mayor and strong-chair budgets for 2027 should therefore come in January, with the strong-mayor deadline of Feb. 1. That includes Barrie, whose 2026 budget was adopted in November 2025.

However, the City of Orillia has scheduled Budget Committee deliberations on "the Mayor's Proposed 2027 Capital and Operating Budget" for Dec. 8 to 10, 2026. The Voice could not confirm how that schedule fits the June regulation.

Pressures. Clarke told OrilliaMatters that the City faces several increases before council touches its own budget:

about $1.1 million more for the OPP

about $1 million more for the County

a higher Simcoe Muskoka District Health Unit levy

staff raises near 3 per cent

Together, he said, those bring the tax rate increase to ‘4 to 4.5 per cent before infrastructure and any other demands are added.’ ‘So the budget is going to be a challenge,’ he said.

What taxpayers should watch

Dec. 8: McIsaac is sworn in. Watch for any chair directions on the 2027 County budget.

January 2027: the first County budget proposed by an appointed chair. Every member municipality, and the County's charges to Barrie and Orillia, depend on it.

Barrie: whether Nuttall seeks a fifth straight 0 per cent operating increase.

Orillia: how the December budget schedule squares with the provincial timing rule.

Sources

Ontario Newsroom, "Ontario Appoints Heads of Council in Eight Upper-Tier Municipalities" (Nov. 10, 2026): https://news.ontario.ca/en/release/1008262/ontario-appoints-heads-of-council-in-eight-upper-tier-municipalities

County of Simcoe, "Governance Changes at the County of Simcoe": https://simcoe.ca/government/countychaircao/governance-changes-at-the-county-of-simcoe/

County of Simcoe, "Upcoming Governance Changes at the County of Simcoe" (inaugural date): https://simcoe.ca/upcoming-governance-changes-at-the-county-of-simcoe/

County of Simcoe, County Chair page: https://simcoe.ca/government/countychaircao/county-chair/

OrilliaMatters, "Don McIsaac appointed chair of Simcoe County council": https://www.orilliamatters.com/local-news/breaking-don-mcisaac-appointed-chair-of-simcoe-county-council-13000700

OrilliaMatters/BarrieToday, "Tears, tributes mark final county council meeting before downsizing": https://www.orilliamatters.com/local-news/tears-tributes-mark-final-county-council-meeting-before-downsizing-13007628

Barrie360, "Five mayors defeated across municipal elections in Simcoe County": https://barrie360.com/simcoe-county-mayoral-election-results-2026/

Barrie360, "Here's a list of elected mayors and councillors across Simcoe County": https://barrie360.com/simcoe-county-municipalities-elected-list-26/

City of Barrie, 2026 Official Election Results: https://www.barrie.ca/government-news/2026-municipal-election/2026-official-election-results

City of Barrie, Inaugural Council meeting agenda (Nov. 18, 2026): https://pub-barrie.escribemeetings.com/Meeting.aspx?Agenda=Agenda&Id=994c84e9-7e86-4810-8bac-3095307cb27f&lang=English

Barrie360, "Nuttall wins second term as Barrie mayor": https://barrie360.com/nuttall-wins-second-term-as-barrie-mayor/

CompassNews, "Barrie council backs Mayor Nuttall's 2026 budget with zero per cent tax increase": https://compassnews.ca/barrie-council-backs-mayor-nuttalls-2026-budget-with-zero-per-cent-tax-increase/

City of Orillia, Certificate of Election Results: https://media-001-ca.cdn.govstack.com/orilliarecreation-004-ca/media/deinceq5/2026-certificate-of-election-results-city-of-orillia-final.pdf

OrilliaMatters, "It's official: Clarke returns as Orillia's mayor": https://www.orilliamatters.com/2026-municipal-election-news/breaking-steve-clarke-has-big-early-lead-in-mayors-race-12941861

OrilliaMatters, "New mayor vows civility, promises council will be 'productive'": https://www.orilliamatters.com/2026-municipal-election-news/new-mayor-vows-civility-promises-council-will-be-productive-12957255

SUNonline/Orillia, "Clarke Wins": https://sunonlinemedia.ca/2026/10/27/clarke-wins/

City of Orillia, Budget Committee notice, Mayor's Proposed 2027 Budget: https://www.orillia.ca/news-and-notices/posts/public-notice-budget-committee-meeting-re-deliberations-on-the-mayor-s-proposed-2027-capital-and-operating-budget/

County of Simcoe, "2026 County of Simcoe Budget approved by Council" (Nov. 25, 2025): https://simcoe.ca/2026-county-of-simcoe-budget-approved-by-council/

Ontario Regulation 189/26: https://www.ontario.ca/laws/regulation/r26189